The media precedent: sport holds the fan relationship but leaves the data to others

Sports organisations risk repeating the media precedent by leaving their data to third parties.

Follow the same person onto a media property and onto a club's website. On the media property, hundreds of tech companies that person has never heard of receive a record of the visit within milliseconds. On the club's site, almost nothing happens: the club ends the visit knowing as little about the fan as it did before. More than that. Often, sports content is published on a third-party platform, be it Instagram, YouTube, TikTok or others, growing the platform's audience, allowing it to collect more data and leaving the club more dependent. Swap a club for a league or an athlete, and the situation is often identical.

Take a mirror, bring media companies in front of it, and you will see sports organisations appear, but with an inverted image. 

Historically, media companies understood the importance of collecting their users’ data but leaked it to their tech partners, letting them monetise most of it and losing the relationship with the audience along the way. Sports organisations hold the relationship, but many of them are already leaving the data to third parties.

Operating on both sides, I find it amusing and frustrating how sports organisations compare to media in monetising engagement. This is not about the shirt sponsor, but the media revenue opportunity lying next to it, the revenue that a club's own audience and content could and should be generating.

How media lost the data and the audience relationship

Traditional media owners have become obsessed with data, and rightly so. The problem is how and what they have been doing with it: alienating their audiences through extractive approaches to data collection for "data-driven" advertising that butchered the user experience and became one of the main reasons for the disaffection of those audiences.

That was not media companies' initiative alone. Since the mid-2000s, advertising technology companies have persuaded the media brands that had a direct relationship with their audiences, "readers" and "viewers", that they could not survive without letting intermediaries bundle their assets, including data, in the name of extreme reach to satisfy advertisers' needs. They handed over two things at once. The data was leaked through the integrations they willingly allowed to be put in place. The relationship went with it, destroyed by the same bad data practices, which caused a loss of trust, by intrusive advertising formats and by the overall experience that those integrations produced.

So, "people", "customers", "clients" become "IDs". Interests and passions become "signals" and "data points". Data belonging to media audiences has been flying around the digital advertising ecosystem, making intermediaries rich and leaving the crumbs to the companies that have the direct relationship with the audience, create the content and technically own the data.

The cost for media today

The bill has now arrived. The growth of zero-click search is seriously affecting media revenues by removing the visits that search used to send to their digital properties, in many cases halving their traffic, if not worse. In the two years to July 2026, the 50 biggest news sites in the US lost 37% of their monthly visits, from 4.9 billion to 3.1 billion.

A loyal, engaged audience would visit them directly and not be satisfied by a short summary on Google, but it has become smaller and smaller for the reasons I listed above.

I call it the media precedent. A category that once held the relationship with the audience gave away the data that relationship produced, then lost the relationship itself, partly because of how that data was used.

Where sport stands now

The top four or five football clubs in each country have started building their own picture of the fans and the infrastructure to interact with them. For the majority below them, and across most other disciplines, neither exists in-house. Available budget is part of the barrier between the two groups, but not the main one.

Most clubs already hold more fan data than they use, through their ticketing, membership and retail contracts, but that picture of the fan is being built by the commercial, technology and data partners behind those contracts, not by the club. What is missing is the strategic decision to treat the fanbase as an audience, to see the revenue opportunity it represents besides traditional sponsorships, and a structure that makes it happen. That requires resources, but resources follow a strategic choice, not the other way round.

Media set the precedent in both directions: what to build, and what not to lose control of. Sports organisations and athletes should take note and use the opportunity to avoid the mistakes, the blood and the tears.

The Media Precedent is also my practice. I help the sports industry develop additional sponsorship and advertising revenue from the audience, data and content they already own.

Subscribe to The Media Precedent newsletter

Audience monetisation strategies for sports organisations, athletes and sportstech platforms. Subscribe for free.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe